logo inner

Manager, Specialty Claims

FortegraIselin, New Jersey, United StatesOnsite

The Manager, Specialty Claims will report to the Vice President, Specialty Claims. We are seeking a highly skilled and experienced Claims Manager to lead and manage complex and high-severity recovery claims, including subrogation, litigation, and attorney-managed claims. This role involves direct oversight of all recovery efforts, legal strategies, negotiation efforts, and collaboration with internal and external stakeholders. Additionally, the Claims Manager will be responsible for conducting detailed claim audits to ensure accuracy, consistency, and compliance with internal standards and regulatory requirements.

Minimum Qualifications:


  • Bachelor's degree in Business Administration, Accounting, Finance or a related field, or equivalent experience.
  • At least 10 years of relevant and progressive experience in Subrogation, Quality Assurance, and Liability Claims.
  • Adjuster's license, as mandated by specific states, are required.

Primary Job Functions:


  • Manage all aspects of the subrogation claims process—from identification through recovery—ensuring efficient and timely handling.
  • Analyze open and closed claims for subrogation opportunities by reviewing reports, liability information, and supporting documentation.
  • Direct management of recovery specialists and external legal counsel to pursue recoveries through negotiation, litigation, or arbitration.
  • Ensure all subrogation activities comply with state and federal insurance laws, as well as company policies and procedures.
  • Track and report on KPIs such as recovery rate, cycle time, and cost-effectiveness; use data to improve processes.
  • Design and refine workflows and strategies to improve efficiency, recovery rates, and cost control.
  • Audit claim files across multiple lines of business to ensure claim handling meets internal standards and regulatory requirements.
  • Participate in claim reviews and claim audits.
  • Attend settlement conferences and trials when necessary.
  • Performs other duties or special projects as required or assigned by a supervisor.

The above-cited duties and responsibilities describe the general nature and level of work performed by people assigned to the job.  They are not intended to be an exhaustive list of all the duties and responsibilities that an incumbent may be expected or asked to perform.

Skills & Competencies Required:


  • Excellent written and verbal communication skills.
  • Strong analytical skills.
  • Strong negotiation skills.
  • In-depth knowledge of claims, litigation, and trial process.
  • Excellent organizational and time management skills.
  • Proficiency in MS Office (Word, Excel, Outlook).
  • Ability to successfully obtain the required state adjusters’ licenses.

Additional Information:


Full benefit package including medical, dental, life, vision, company paid short/long term disability, 401(k), tuition assistance and more.#LI-Onsite

Life at Fortegra

Fortegra is a professional services firm specializing in business and technology consulting services for the energy and utility industries. Since 1996, Fortegra has been committed to delivering premier management consulting and systems integration solutions for many of the largest energy and utility companies across North America. With deep industry and business process knowledge, along with a proven track record, Fortegra serves its clients with significant product and technology expertise in CIS and billing, scheduling and settlements, and other systems supporting customer care and field operations.
Thrive Here & What We Value- Fast-paced, rapidly changing work environment- Full benefit package (medical, dental, vision, life insurance, short/long term disability, 401(k), tuition assistance)- Collaborative and results-driven culture- Entrepreneurial mindset with a focus on business growth- Strong analytical skills, empathy, service orientation, strategic thinking, proactivity, attention to detail, organizational skills- Celebrates diversity and inclusion- Prioritizes employee well-being- Confidentiality as per EEOC guidelines
Your tracker settings

We use cookies and similar methods to recognize visitors and remember their preferences. We also use them to measure ad campaign effectiveness, target ads and analyze site traffic. To learn more about these methods, including how to disable them, view our Cookie Policy or Privacy Policy.

By tapping `Accept`, you consent to the use of these methods by us and third parties. You can always change your tracker preferences by visiting our Cookie Policy.

logo innerThatStartupJob
Discover the best startup and their job positions, all in one place.
Copyright © 2025